For those who have been mourning the loss of beloved sandwich shop City Sub since it unceremoniously closed its doors after more than 25 years in business on Bergen Street near Fifth Avenue on May of 2014, pledging to just be moving "up the block to a new location," it appears as if that new location has finally materialized: Park Slope Stoop is reporting that a temporary sign has gone up in the window of the former Nuteria (on Fifth between St. Marks and Warren), announcing that a new restaurant called City Subs is moving in.
City Sub, which was one of the only storefronts in the area that commanded lines out the door on a near-daily basis, was a no-frills sandwich shop selling a wide variety of simple cold cut sandwiches and a few hot ones, like meatball. It's hard to say what exactly made it so good; it was quite possibly the freshness of the super-thin-sliced meat sliced to order, or maybe the sesame seed-topped bread from Carroll Gardens-based Mazzola Bakery. Whatever the reason, these were some seriously good old-school sandwiches.
I think we have very good reason to be cautiously optimistic here that this is in fact the second coming of City Sub: The logo and name are essentially the same as they were before, they said when they closed that they'd be re-opening up the block, and... well, that's about it, but it's enough to go on for now. Possibly it's under new ownership; City Sub's closing notice was written by "the staff of City Sub," not the owners. And even if it's not City Sub reopening, any new sandwich shop is one that's worth getting excited about.
Photo via Park Slope Stoop.